# A Comprehensive Review on Impact of Wind and Solar Photovoltaic Energy Sources on Voltage Stability of Power Grid

### Abstract

The concern for ever increasing demand for electricity, progressive depletion of fossil fuels, reduction in carbon footprint, improved infrastructure reliability, etc. have encouraged the power utility companies to adopt renewable energy sources in conventional power systems. The enhanced penetration of non-dispachable renewable energy sources such as solar photovoltaic (PV) and wind energy into existing distribution and transmission networks had led to various issues of concern regarding system voltage stability. This paper presents a detailed study of the important issues such as optimum location and sizing of distributed generation (DG) units from voltage stability viewpoint, assessmentof voltage instability in the renewable integrated system and its enhancement with employment of devices such as fixed capacitors, flexible A. C. transmission system (FACTS) and energy storage system (ESS) into transmission and distribution networks. The review results provide a comprehensive background for the voltage stability investigation in non-dispatchable renewable integrated power systems with major outcomes and findings of future research work in the field of power system stability.

### References

Ajjarapu, V. & Christy, C. 1992. The continuation power flow: A tool for steady state voltage stability analysis. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 7(1): 416-423.

Ajjarapu, V. & Lee B. 1992. Bifurcation theory and its application to nonlinear dynamical phenomena in an electrical power system. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 7(1): 424-431.

Ajjarapu, V. 2009. Computational techniques for voltage stability assessment and control, Springer, India.

Al Abri, R. S., El-Saadany, E. F., & Atwa, Y. M. 2013. Optimal placement and sizing method to improve the voltage stability margin in a distribution system using distributed generation. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 28(1): 326-334.

Almeida, A. B., Lorenci, E. V. D., Leme, R. C., Souza, A. C. Z. D., Lopes, B. I. L., & Lo, K. 2013. Probabilistic voltage stability assessment considering renewable sources with the help of the PV and QV curves. IET Renewable Power Generation, 7(5): 521-530.

Alvarado, F. Dobson, I., & Hu, Y. 1994. Computation of closest bifurcations in power systems. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 9(2): 918-928.

Aly, M. M., Abdel-Akher, M., Ziadi, Z., & Senjyu, T. 2014. Assessment of reactive power contribution of photovoltaic energy systems on voltage profile and stability of distribution systems. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems, 61:665-672.

Aman, M. M., Jasmon, G. B., Bakar, A. H. A., & Mokhlis, H. 2014. A new approach for optimum simultaneous multi DG distributed generation units placement and sizing based on maximization of system loadability using HPSO (hybrid particle swarm optimization) algorithm. Energy, 66:202-215.

Atwa, Y. M., El-Saadany, E. F., Salama, M. M. A., & Seethapathy R. 2010. Optimal renewable resources mix for distribution system energy loss minimization. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 25(1):360-370.

Beiraghi, M. & Ranjbar, A. M. 2013. Online voltage security assessment based on wide area measurements. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, 28(2): 989-997.

Bueno, P. G., Hernandez, J. C., & Ruiz-Rodriguez, F. J. 2016. Stability assessment for transmission systems with large utility scale photovoltaic units. IET Renewable Power Generation, 10(5):584-597.

Corsi, S. & Taranto, G. N. 2008. A real-time voltage instability identification algorithm based on local phasor measurements. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 23(3):1271-1279.

Cutsem, T. V. 2000. Voltage Instability: phenomena, countermeasures, and analysis methods. Proceedings of IEEE, 88(2): 208-227.

Diao, R., Sun, K., Vittal, V., O'Keefe, R. J., Richardson, M. R., Bhatt, N., Stradford, D., & Sarawgi S. K. 2009. Decision tree based online voltage security assessment using PMU measurements. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 24(2): 832-834.

Dobson, I. & Lu, L. 1993. New methods for computing a closest saddle node bifurcation and worst case load power margin for voltage collapse. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 8(3): 905-913.

Du, W., Zhou, M., & Lin, B., & Yang, G. 2013. Photovoltaic power penetration capacity assessment considering static voltage stability. In: Proceedings of IEEE PES Asia-Pacific power and energy engineering conference (APPEEC), Kowloon, China, 1-6.

Eftekharnejad, S., Vittal, V., Heydt, G. T., Keel, B., & Loehr, J. 2013. Impact of increased penetration of photovoltaic generation on power systems. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 28(2): 893-901.

Eftekharnejad, S., Vittal, V., Heydt, G. T., Keel, B., & Loehr, J. 2013. Small signal stability assessment of power systems with increased penetration of photovoltaic generation: a case study. IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, 4(4): 960-967.

EL-Dib, A. A., Youssef, H. K. M., EL- Metwally, M. M., & Osman Z. 2006. Maximum loadability of power systems using hybrid particle swarm optimization. Electric Power Systems Research, 76(6):485-492.

El-Keib, A. A. & Ma X. 1995. Application of artificial neural networks in voltage stability assessment. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 10(4):1890-1896.

Esmaili, M., Firozjaee, E. C., & Shayanfar, H. A. 2014. Optimal placement of distributed generations considering voltage stability and power losses with observing voltage related constraints. Applied Energy, 113:1252-1260.

Esmalili, M. 2013. Placement of minimum distributed generation units observing power losses and voltage stability with network constraints. IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 7(8):813-821.

Ettehadi, M., Ghasemi, H., & Vaez-Zadeh, S. 2013. Voltage stability based DG placement in distribution networks. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, 28(1):171-178.

Flatabo, N., Ognedal, R., & Carlson, T. 1990. Voltage stability condition in a power transmission system calculated by sensitivity methods. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 5(4):1286-1293.

Gao, B., Morison, G. K., & Kundur, P. 1992. Voltage stability evaluation using modal analysis. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 7(4):1529-1542.

Glavic, M. & Cutsem, T. V. 2009. Wide area detection of voltage instability from synchronized phasor measurements. part II: simulation results, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 24(3): 1417-1425.

Glavic, M. & Cutsem, T. V. 2009. Wide area detection of voltage instability from synchronized phasor measurements. part I: principle. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 24(3):1408-1416.

Glavic, M., Novosel, D., Heredia, E., Kosterev, D., Salazar, A., Ashrafi, F. H., & Donnelly M. 2012. See it fast to keep calm: real time voltage control under stressed conditions. IEEE Power and Energy Magzine, 10(4): 43-55.

Ha, L.T. & Saha, T. K. 2004. Investigation of power loss and voltage stability limits for large wind farm connections to a subtransmission network. Proceedings of IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, Denver, USA, 2251-2256.

Haesen, E., Bastiaensen, C., Driesen, J., & Belmans R. 2009. A probabilistic formulation of load margins in power systems with stochastic generation. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 24(2):951-958.

Han, C., Huang, A. Q., Baran, M. E., Bhattacharya, S., Litzenberger, W., Andersn, L., Johnson, A. L., & Edris, A. A. 2008. STATCOM impact study on the integration of a large wind farm into a weak power loop power system. IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, 23(1):226-233.

Haque, M. H., 2016. Impacts of fixed speed wind generators on static voltage stability of distribution systems. Proceedings of 4th International conference on the development in the renewable energy technology(ICDRET), Dhaka, Bangladesh, 1-6.

He, L. & Liu, C. C. 2014. Parameter identification with PMUs for instability detection in power systems with HVDC integrated offshore wind energy. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 29(2): 775-784.

Hossain, J., & Pota, H. R. 2014. Robust Control for Grid Voltage Stability: High Penetration of Renewable Energy. Springer.

Inwai, C. C., Yingvivatanapong, C., Methaprayoon, K., & Lee, W. J. 2005. Reactive compensation techniques to improve the ride through capability of wind turbine during disturbance. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Applications, 41(3): 666-672.

Jiang, H., Zhang, Y., Zhang, J., Gao, D. W., & Muljadi, E. 2015. Synchrophasor based auxiliary controller to enhance the voltage stability of a distribution system with high renewable energy penetration. IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, 6(4):2107-2115.

Kataoka, Y. 2003. A probabilistic nodal loading model and worst case solutions for electric power system voltage stability assessment. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 18(4):1507-1514.

Kawabe, K. & Tanaka, K. 2015. Impact of Dynamic behavior of photovoltaic power generation on short term voltage stability. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 30(6):3416-3424.

Kawabe, K., Ota, Y., Yokoyama, A., & Tanaka, K. 2017. Noval dynamic voltage support capability of photovoltaic systems for improvement of short term voltage stability in power systems. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 32(3): 1796-1804.

Kayal, P., & Chanda, C. K. 2015. Optimal mix of solar and wind distribution generation consider performance improvement of electrical distribution network. Renewable Energy, 75:173-186.

Kehrli, A. & Ross, M. 2003. Understanding grid integration issues at wind farms and solutions using voltage source converter FACTS technology. Proceedings of IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, Toronto, Canada, 1822-1828.

Konar, S., Chatterjee, D., & Patra, S. 2015. V-Q sensitivity based index for assessment of dynamic voltage stability of power systems. IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 9(7): 677-685.

Kundur, P. 2011. Power System Stability and Control. Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi, India.

Kundur, P., Paserba, J., Ajjarapu, V., Anderson, G., Bose, A., Canizares, C., Hatizargriou, N., Hill, D., Stankovic, A., Taylor, C., Cutsem, T. V., & Vittal, V. 2004. Definition and classification of power system stability- IEEE joint task force on stability terms and definitions. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 19(3):1387-1401.

Kuru, L., Ozturk, A., Kuru, E., & Kandara, O. 2015. Determination of voltage stability boundary values in electrical power systems by using the chaotic particle swarm optimization algorithm. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems, 64: 873-879.

Le, H. T., Santoso, S., & Nguyen, T. Q. 2012. Augmenting wind power penetration and grid voltage stability limits using ESS: Application design, sizing and a case study. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 27(1):161-171.

Leite da Silva, A. M., Coutinho, I. P., Zambroni de Souza, A. C., Prada, R. B., & Rei, A. M. 2000. Voltage collapse risk assessment. Electric Power System Research, 54(3):221-227.

Li, J., Li, Y., Fan, R., Liu, F., Cao Y., & Chen S. 2016. An impedance modulus margin based approach for voltage stability evaluation of distribution networks with wind power generations. In: Proceedings of IEEE 16th international conference on environmental and electrical engineering (EEEIC), Florence, Italy, 1-5.

Liew, S. N. & Strbac, G. 2002. Maximum penetration of wind generation in existing distribution networks. IEE Proceedings- Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 149(3):256-262.

Liu, J. H. & Chu, C. C. 2015. Long term voltage instability detections of multiple fixed speed induction generators in distribution networks using synchrophasor. IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, 6(4):2069-2079.

Liu, J. H., & Chu, C. C. 2014. Wide area measurement based voltage instability indicators by modified coupled single port models. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 29(2):756-764.

Liu, S., Liu, P. X., & Wang X. 2016. Stochastic small signal stability analysis of grid connected photovoltaic systems. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 63(2):1027-1238.

Liu, Z., Wen, F., & Ledwich, G. 2011. Optimal siting and sizing of distributed generators in distribution systems considering uncertainties. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, 26(4): 2541-2551.

Mitsugi, Y., & Yokoyama, A. 2014. Phase angle and voltage stability assessment in multi machine power system with massive integration of PV considering PVs FRT requirements and dynamic load characteristics. Proceedings of IEEE international conference on power system technology (POWERCON), Chengdu, China, 1112-1119.

Modarresi, J., Gholipour, E., & Khodabakhshian, A. 2016. A comprehensive review of the voltage stability indices. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 63:1-12.

Modarresi, J., Gholipour, E., Khodabakhshian, A. 2016. A comprehensive review of the voltage stability indices. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 63(1):1-12.

Mohammadi, H. & Behghani, M. 2015. PMU based voltage securing assessment of power systems exploiting principal component analysis and decision trees. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems, 64:655-663.

Molinas, M., Suul, J. A., & Undeland, T. 2008. Low voltage ride through of wind farms with cage generators: STATCOM versus SVC. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 23(3):1104-1117.

Mu-Chun, S., Chih-Wen, L., & Chen-Sun, C. 1999. Rule extraction for voltage security margin estimation. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 46(6):1114-1122.

Munoz, J., Canizares, C., Bhattacharya, K., & Vaccaro, A. 2013. An affine arithmetic based method for voltage stability assessment of power systems with intermittent generation sources. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 28(4): 4475-4487.

Murthy, V. V. S. N. & Kumar A. 2015. Optimal placement of DG in radial distribution systems based on new voltage stability index under load growth. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy System, 69:246-256.

Overbye, T. J. & De-Marco C. L. 1991. Improved techniques for power system voltage stability assessment using energy methods. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 6(4): 1446-1452.

Overbye, T. J. 1993. Use of energy methods for on-line assessment of power system voltage security. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 8(2):452-458.

Poornazaryan, B., Karimyan, P., Gharehpetian, G. B., & Abedi, M. 2016. Optimal location and sizing of DG units considering voltage stability, losses and load variations. International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy System, 79: 42-52.

Popovic, D., Kukolj, D., & Kulic F. 1998. Monitoring and assessment of voltage stability margins using artificial neural networks with a reduced input set. IEE Proceedings- Generation Transmission and Distribution, 154(4):355-362.

Prakash, P. & Khatod, D. K. 2016. Optimal sizing and siting techniques for distributed generation in distribution system: a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 57:111-130.

Renewable Capacity Statistics 2017, http://www.irena.org//media/Files/IRENA /Agency/Publication/2017/Jul/ IRENA_Renewable_Energy_Statistics_2017.pdf , 2018-06-25.

Rodrigues, A. B., Prada, R., & Da Guia da Silva, M. 2010. Voltage stability probabilistic assessment in composite systems: Modeling unsolvability and contrlollability loss. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 25(3): 1575-1588.

Roy, N. K., Pota, H. R., & Hossain, M. J. 2013. Reactive power management of distribution networks with wind generation for improving voltage stability. Renewable Energy, 58:85-94.

Saad-Saoud, Z., Lisboa, M. L., Ekanayake, J. B., Jenkins, N., & Strbac, G. 1998. Application of STATCOMs to wind farms. IEE Proceedings- Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 145(5):511-516.

Sajan, K. S., Kumar V., & Tyagi B. 2015. Genetic algorithm based support vector machine for on line voltage stability monitoring, International Journal of Electric Power and Energy Systems, 73: 200-208.

Schellenberg, A., Rosehart, W., & Agado, J. 2006. Cumulant based stochastic nonlinear programming for variance constrained voltage stability analysis of power systems. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 21(2): 579-585.

Shah, R., Mithulananthan, N., Bansal, R. C., & Ramachandraramurthy V. K. 2015. A review of key power system stability challenges for large scale PV integration. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 41:1423-1436.

Smith, J. W. & Brooks, D. L. 2001. Voltage impacts of distributed wind generation on rural distribution feeders. Proceedings of IEEE/PES Transmission Distribution Conference and Exposition Developing New Perspectives, Atlanta, USA, 492-497.

Smon, I., Verbic, G., & Gubina, F. 2006. Local voltage-stability index using Tellegen’s theorem. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 21(3): 1267-1275.

Sultana, U., Khairddin, A. B., Aman, M. M., Mokhtar, A. S., & Zareen, N. 2016. A review of optimum DG placement based on minimization of power losses and voltage stability enhancement of distribution system. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 63:363-378.

Tamimi, A. A., Pahwa, A., & Starrett, S. 2012. Effective wind farm sizing method for weak power systems using critical modes of voltage instability. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 27(3):1610-1617.

Tamimi, B., Canizares, C., & Bhattacharya, K. 2013. System stability impact of large scale and distributed solar photovoltaic generation: The case of ontario, Canada. IEEE Transactions on Sustainable Energy, 4(3): 680-688.

Tan, Y. T. & Kirschen D. S. 2007. Impact on the power system of a large penetration of photovoltaic generation, Proceedings of IEEE Power Engineering Society Geneneral Meeting, Tampa, USA, 1-8.

Tso, S. K., Zhu, T. X., Zeng, Q. Y., & Lo, K. L. 1995. Fuzzy-set approach to dynamic voltage security assessment. IEE Proceedings- Generation, Transmission and Distribution, 142(2):190-194.

Tso, S. K., Zhu, T. X., Zeng, Q. Y., & Lo, K. L. 1996. Fuzzy reasoning for knowledge-based assessment of dynamic voltage security. IEE Proceedings- Generation, Transmission, and Distribution, 143(2): 157-162.

Venkatesh, B., Rost, A., & Chang L. 2007. Dynamic voltage collapse index- wind generator application. IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, 22(1): 90-94.

Verschueren, T., Mets, K., Meersman, B., Strobbe, M., Develder, C., & Vandevelde, L. 2011. Assessment and mitigation of voltage violations by solar panels in a residential distribution grid. Proceedings of IEEE international conference on smart grid communications (Smart Grid Comm), Brussels, Belgium, 540-545.

Vu, K., Begovic, M. M., Novosel, D., & Saha, M. M. 1999. Use of local measurements to estimate voltage stability margin. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 14(3):1029-1235.

Wang, Y, Chiang, H. D., & Wang, T. 2013. A two stage method for assessment of voltage stability in power system with renewable energy. In: Proceedings of IEEE Electrical power & energy conference (EPEC), Halifax, Canada, 1-6.

Wang, Y., Pordanjani, I. R., Li, W., Xu, W., Chen, T., Vaahedi, E., & Gurney, J. 2011. Voltage Stability Monitoring Based on the concept of coupled single port circuit. IEEE Transaction on Power Systems, 26(4): 2154-2163.

Xiuhong, Z, Kewen, W, Ming, L, Wanhui, Y, & Tse, C. T. 2002. Two extended approaches for voltage stability studies of quadratic and probabilistic continuation load flow. In: Proceedings of IEEE international conference on Power System Technology (PowerCon), Kunming, China, 1705-1709.

Xu, J., Kanyingi, P. K., Wang, K., Li, G., Han, B., & Jiang, X. 2017. Probabilistic small signal stability analysis with large scale integration of wind power considering dependence. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 69:1258-1270.

Xue, Y., Manjrekar, M., Lin, C., Tamayo, M., & Jiang, J. N. 2011. Voltage stability and sensitivity analysis of grid-connected photovoltaic systems. In: Proceedings of IEEE Power Energy Society General Meeting, Detroit, USA, 1-7.

Yan, R. & Saha, T. K. 2012. Investigation of voltage stability for residential customers due to high photovoltaic penetrations. IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, 27(2): 651-662.

Zhou, F., Joos, G., & Abbey, C. 2005. Voltage stability in weak connection wind farms. Proceedings of IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, San Francisco, USA, 1483-1488.