A framework for an on-demand dangerous goods routing support system for the metro Vancouver area
Abstract
This paper proposes a framework that integrates existing climate conditions with a GeographicalInformation System (GIS) to develop an on-demand dangerous goods (DG) routing supportsystem. The framework focuses on mitigating the risks associated with DG transportationvia route selection. Evidently, DG routing involves a number of decisions that require theconsideration of multiple and sometimes conflicting risks. As a result, the framework includesa number of different routing criteria pertaining to safety, efficiency, security, and cost.The framework was applied to a large-scale transportation network representing the MetroVancouver area. The network was represented spatially in a GIS database along with a real-timedispersion plume model to simulate a specific chemical release under local weather conditions.The results show that different routing criteria lead to different optimal route choices. Theauthors also compared route selection based on the Emergency Response Guidebook (ERG)for protection and isolation actions with route selection based on dispersion models. Thecomparison results show that, when employing the ERG in a small spill scenario, decisionmakersare at risk of exposing a large number of individuals to severe health effects. Vice versa,if the ERG was to be followed in a large spill scenario, many individuals who are not at riskwould be unnecessarily evacuated. This translates into increased evacuation costs, and wastesthe time and effort of emergency personnel. The study shows that these issues are properlyaddressed if a dispersion model is used to refine the estimation of the impact zone by includingmeasures that are specific to the shipment.
References
Covellov, T. & Merkhofer, M. W. 1993. Risk assessment methods: Approaches for assessing health and
environmental risks. Plenum Press, NY.
Erkut, E. & Verter, V. 1998. Modeling of transport risk for hazardous materials. Operational Research
Letters. 46, 625-642.
USDOT (U.S. Department of Transportation) 1989. Guidelines for applying criteria to designate routes
for transporting hazardous materials. Report No. DOT/RSPA/OHMT- 89-02, Federal Highway
Administration, Washington, DC.
Abkowitz, M., Eiger, A. & Srinivasan, S. 1984. Estimating the release rates and costs of transporting
hazardous waste. Transportation Research Record 977: 22-30.
Pijawka, K., Foote S. & Soesilo, A. 1985. Risk assessment of transporting hazardous material: Route
analysis and hazard management. Transportation Research Record 1020: 1-6.
A framework for an on-demand dangerous goods routing support system for the metro Vancouver area 38
Radwan, E., Pijawka, K., Soesilo, A. & Shieh, F. 1986. Transportation of hazardous wastes in Arizona:
Development of a data base management system for basic analysis. Transportation Research
Record 1063: 1-7.
Abkowitz, M. & Cheng, P. D. M. 1988. Developing a risk/cost framework for routing truck movements
of hazardous materials. Accident Analysis & Prevention, 20(1):39-51.
Glickman, Theodore, S. 1991. An expeditious risk assessment of the highway transportation of flammable
liquids in bulk. Transportation Science 25:115- 123.
Harwood, W. D., Viner J. G. & Russell, E. R. 1991. Truck accident and release rates for hazmat routing.
ASCE Conference Proceeding Paper 177-190.
Harwood, W. D., Viner, J. G. & Russell, E. R. 1993. Procedure for developing truck accident and release
rates for hazmat routing. Journal of Transportation Engineering 119:189-199.
Saccomanno, F. & Shortreed, J. 1993. HAZMAT Transport risks: Societal and individual perspectives.
Journal of Transportation Engineering 119:177-188.
Erkut, E. & Ingolfsson, A. 2004. Transport risk models for hazardous materials: Revisited. Operational
Research Letters 33: 81-89.
Leonelli, P., Bonvicini, S. & Spadoni G. 2000. Hazardous materials transportation: A risk analysis based
routing methodology. Journal of Hazardous Materials 71: 283-300.
Huang, B., Cheu, R. L. & Liew, Y. S. 2003. GIS-AHP model for HAZMAT routing with security
considerations. IEEE 6th International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems, Shanghai,
China.
Huang, B., Cheu, R. L. & Liew, Y. S. 2004. GIS and genetic algorithms for HAZMAT route planning with
security considerations. International Journal Geographical Information Science 18(8): 769–787.
Dilgir, R., Zein, S. R. & Popoff, A. l 2005. Dangerous goods route selection criteria. Paper prepared for
presentation at the Towards a Safer Road Network Session of the 2005 Annual Conference of the
Transportation Association of Canada Calgary, Alberta.
Han, K. 2006. Developing a GIS-based decision support system for transportation system planning. Paper
submitted to AASHTO GIS-T 2006 Student Paper Contest.
Panwhar, S. T., Pitt, Robert. & Anderson, M. D. 2000. Development of a GIS-Based hazardous
materials transportation management system. Publication of the University Transportation Centre
for Alabama. Report 99244.
Nema, A. K. & Gupta, S. K. 2003. Multiobjective risk analysis and optimization of regional hazardous
waste management system. Practice Periodical of Hazardous, Toxic, and Radioactive Waste
Management. ASCE 69-77.
Huang, B. & Fery, P. 2005. Multiobjective optimization for hazardous materials transportation.
Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board 64-73
Zhang, M., Ma, Y. & Wen, K. 2005. Location-routing model of hazardous materials distribution system
based on risk bottleneck. ICSSSM 1: 362-368. Proceedings of ICSSSM ‘05. 2005 International
Conference on Services Systems and Services Management.
Frank, W. C., Thill, J. C. & Batta, R. 2000. Spatial decision support system for hazardous material truck
routing. Transportation Research Part C 8: 337-359.
Jin, H., Batta, R. & Karwan, M. H. 1995. On the analysis of two new models for transporting hazardous
materials operations research 44(5): 710-723
Lepofsky, M., Abkowitz, M. & Cheng, P. 1993. Transportation hazard analysis in integrated GIS
environment. Journal of Transportation Engineering 119(2): 239-254.
Brainard, J., Lovett, A. & Parfitt, T. J. 1996. Assessing hazardous waste transport risks using a GIS.
International Journal of Geographical Information Systems 10: 831–849.
Karim El-Basyouny and Tarek Sayed
Lovett, A, Parfitt J. P. & Brainard, J. S. 1997. Using GIS in risk analysis: A case study of hazardous
waste transport. Risk Anal 17(5): 625-33.
Emergency Response Guidebook 2008. US Department of Transportation, Transport Canada, Secretariat
of Transport and Communications of Mexico.
Shortreed, J., Belluz, D., Saccomanno, F. F., Nassar, S., Craig, L. & Paoli, G. 1994. Transportation risk
assessment for the Alberta special waste management system (Final Report). Waterloo, Ontario,
Canada: Institute for Risk Research, University of Waterloo.
Waters, W. G., Wong, C. & Megale, K. 1995. Value of commercial vehicle time savings for the evaluation
of highway investment a resource saving approach. Journal of public Economics 35.
